Rekindle Your Wild Joy and Deep Belonging to the Earth

All Sentient Beings November 23, 2009

(This essay was originally published in Tricycle: The Buddhist Review, special section: “Dharma Dogs – Do dogs have Buddha-nature?” Summer 1999,  pp.54-59)


I am the chosen life-companion of a part wolf. As her years were growing long, I became concerned about the quality of her life. Then I heard that a Tibetan Lama, the venerable Kusum Lingpa Rinpoche, would be coming to offer Longevity Empowerments in the town where Grendel and I lived.

Now, the various Buddhisms are reputed to be for all sentient beings. Part of the Bodhissatva vow is not to accept nirvana until “all sentient beings” have become enlightened. So I expected that Grendel would also be welcome at this event. My whole point of going was to take her, the old lady. I was simply going along as her companion.

When the day came, I packed Grendel into our truck. Then, putting her on  the leash, we walked to the entrance of the hall.

Here we encountered our first humans, and here I made a tactical mistake. In my twelve years with Grendel and a lifetime with other animals before her, one thing I learned is: When traveling with an animal, the name of the game is to make it easier for the rule-makers to accede to your wishes. It’s far better to state your wish as though it’s a done deal. Instead of “Is it all right for my dog to come in?” you say, “It is all right if she comes in, isn’t it?” To which it is easier to answer “Yes.” One little change in words, and the meaning shifts unutterably.

Of course, when you want to get around rules, it is also better not to draw attention to yourself at all. Here I opened my big fat mouth and jokingly asked whether I would need to buy a $15 ticket for the dog as well. The ticket-seller looked at me, and time stopped. She withdrew her hand: “Oh, I don’t know whether dogs are allowed.”

Holding down my rising panic, I asked why not. To my surprise, she replied that she didn’t know. “Probably safety reasons.” So I asked if there were a security officer around with whom I might discuss this.  Relieved to be out of it herself, she went off to fetch one.

A discussion with the security officer ensued about whether it was all right if my dog came in. The gist of it had to do with the potential terrors/distractions such a dog might create in a hall full of spiritual people—peeing on the carpets, biting someone (I assume in a Pentecostal frenzy), barking during the liturgy, shedding large clumps of hair, and spontaneous levitation. (Okay, I admit it: I made that last one up. But the guard made up all the others.) I told the guard that Grendel was an old lady, not likely to raise hell in their church, that she was completely house trained, had not heretofore expressed any need to howl along with music, nor acquired a taste for human flesh. More seriously, I promised that if Grendel started making noise, I’d take her out immediately.

I said all this with a calculatedly reasonable tone to my voice, all the while trying to look very straight and respectable. Not easy when you are accompanied by a large, wolf-like, overly fluffy dog; your clothes are vintage Goodwill and your hair looks like a tumbleweed on acid. Meanwhile, you are trying to persuade this guard that the reason you are not willing to leave the dog tied outside is because, in fact, it’s the dog, not you, who most needs to go in and you, the human, are only functioning as her aide.

The security guard hesitated. I waited. (Waiting is another important thing I’ve learned: Quite often, the other person will decide in your favor just to end the discomfort of the situation.) The guard pondered: “Will you sit in the back?” “Yes!” I replied earnestly, surprised by the easiness of this bargain.

Like the starting of a horse race, the baton was waved in the general direction of the doors, and Grendel and I approached. But the new gatekeeper refused my ticket, saying that it wasn’t the security guard’s place to allow Grendel entrance.

I said nothing.

After awhile, she went to get some other official to be consulted about having a nonhuman among them. When she left, I noticed that no one had been paying attention to this and that nobody was guarding the door anymore. Declining the tantalizing offer of more conflict, Grendel and I just walked on  in.

We hid in the crowd near the merchant stands, and blessedly, nobody else got officious with us. The inner courtyard, where we were being detained, became quite packed. Inside the Lama was performing purification rituals. I noticed a slender man in raggedy, homeless-looking clothes who was holding a cat. So Grendel was not to be the only four-legger in there! I wondered how much trouble he had had getting that cat in there—or himself as he looked so different from the largely rich crowd. I stayed in a far corner, shielding Grendel from all the legs pressing in.

At last the room was ready, and the doors swung open. Grendel and I waited until most of the people had entered, and then, as promised, I took a seat near the back. Grendel lay down quietly at my feet. The man with the cat was in the center section, a bit closer to the Rinpoche.

As Rinpoche spoke in his native Tibetan, an interpreter stationed by his side would simultaneously translate. Both were seated on a large, colorful dais erected on the stage at the front of the hall. There was a long table in front of them, containing ritual offerings, and half a dozen robed monks flanked each side. More monks lined the first two rows in the audience.  The sensual qualities were astounding. There was a riot of saturated color: the monks’ vermilion robes, multicolored tassels hanging off Rinpoche’s baton, jewel colored table coverings, dazzling fruits, handmade books. Then there was the huge cavern of the hall itself: the incense, intermittent sounds of chanting, and perhaps best of all, the intangible quality of the air which had just been cleansed. Simply being in those presences seemed enough.

When the ceremonies began, the interpreter explained that Rinpoche would do some blessings, and that while he chanted, we were to meditate on what he said and allow the energies to enter our beings. It was extraordinarily vivid, and I felt my subtle bodies expand and deepen like the opening lotus he invoked. I hoped that Grendel was having a similar experience, because most of the meaning came directly into me through the chanting. It must have been similarly accessible to Grendel, since the original language was foreign to us both.

Next, Rinpoche blessed a pot of water, and the monks took bowlfuls to the audience. Coming to each person, they offered a bit of the charged water in a spoon no bigger than my thumbnail. When a monk poured a spoonful into my palm, I licked up half of it and offered the rest to Grendel. She licked it off slowly, then took a couple of eager licks until my palm was clean. Strangely, after I licked that water, I felt we’d been charged, changed, like some sort of transformation or cleansing was taking place. Grendel stretched and looked up at me, smiling. I invited her to my side where she could lie next to my chair in the broad aisle. More comfortable, she lay her head back down on her paws and slept or rested and meditated: Who knows?

It was announced that anybody could come forward to receive a personal longevity initiation from Rinpoche. This was what we had come for! People started to talk and get up, and Grendel, thinking the event was over, got up, too. I motioned her back down, and we waited. It appeared that Rinpoche was saying some sort of blessing and then tapping each person with what looked like a car’s fish-eye mirror on a stick with loads of colored rags and ribbons for tassels. After about half an hour, when most of the crowd was back in their seats, I aroused Grendel and we went up the aisle to stand in  line.

Most people were respectful and silent, so the standing-in-line felt like a standing and walking meditation. Slowly we wound our way up toward the dais and waiting monks. I was smiling with joyful, calm expectancy as Grendel and I began to mount the four or five wooden stairs leading up to the stage. Suddenly, a woman began to shout from the front seats. I looked over and saw a well-dressed, middle-aged woman sporting meditation beads and one of those Dharma scarves like I had just bought outside. I saw that she was looking right at us. “Beg pardon?” I asked her. “Are you speaking to us?” “It’s not usually done, you know,” she spat.

“What isn’t?” I asked from my place on the first stair. “Bringing dogs to a ceremony,” she said, as though pronouncing something obscene. “This is a Tantric initiation! Don’t you know what this means? This is very select, and it is only for people! And only certain people! Not for animals!” Her eyes blazed fire at Grendel and me as she howled indignantly, “What’s wrong with you?!”

Her verbal attack hit like a tempered steel blade. I replied weakly, “Let’s just see what the Lama thinks, okay?”

“Sit down! Get that dog out of here!” she was ranting, but under her breath, like a hiss or a hackle-raised growl.

Confused, I turned away, then back to her accusing eyes. I began to wonder, “Just who do I think I am, coming into their ceremony with my ideas? Maybe this is insulting.”

Then I looked ahead at the back of the man in front of me and ahead of him at the robe of a young monk and the promised initiation. In a flash, I remembered the reason I’d come here. Grendel was getting old, and this longevity initiation might benefit her. We were now close to contact with a respected Lama who came from a tradition that purported to be for her as well. I felt my reason and resolve bolster. Turning away from the woman, we advanced to the second step.

I was shaking from the encounter and the continuing glare of the woman’s cold eyes. Grendel undoubtedly felt this, too. As we took two more steps to the top platform, she began, uncharacteristically, to act up. She turned round and round, tangling up the leash and banging into the legs of the man in front of us. He moved on to meet Rinpoche as Grendel and I approached the first monk. He watched while I untangled the leash and asked her to sit. When she complied, the monk commented with a surprised, approving smile, “She’s well behaved.” “Yes,” I snapped, still upset from the earlier attack and Grendel’s incomprehensible actions. “Just like most of the humans here.”

The monk gazing at me with a complex smile. And then he laughed! Next, he said something in Tibetan to the Rinpoche, who was now also watching the scenario. The monk looked towards Grendel, then to Rinpoche, and added in English, smiling, “You know, this is a rare opportunity.” And Rinpoche agreed, nodding and saying also in English, “Yes.”

Hope came alive again. Rinpoche beckoned us forward, and I pushed Grendel to the center first. Rinpoche reached under the table to a blessed rice mixture, and with a gleeful laugh flung it upon her. The people before us had simply received the baton. My heart seemed to bloom with gratitude for the clear wisdom of this monk and this teacher. I knew that I was in the presence of a master who could see the spiritual potential—even divinity—in a body other than his own .

My eyes misted, and with clasped hands, I bowed spontaneously. Behind me, there was a great roar of laughter and applause—I hadn’t realized it, but of course everyone had been watching. They, too,  had undoubtedly wondered what the Rinpoche would make of this.

Rinpoche now beckoned to me: It was my turn. I went up to his platform and offered him my new Dharma scarf. He took it, blessed it, gave it back to me, and touched me on the shoulders with the tasseled baton. Moving on, Grendel and I came to three monks who were proffering blessed goodies of several varieties. And every monk handed me two, one for me and one for Grendel.

I was in a state of stunned silence all the way down the stairs and through the auditorium to the seat we had vacated, it seemed, a lifetime ago. And then the astonished grin came. I just sat there, reeling from the import of what had occurred. How the exact same thing had been spoken twice, and yet worlds apart. A snarled “It’s not usually done” means the same thing cognitively as an awed, “This is a rare opportunity”—the same thing, yet a universe of difference. One little change in words, and the meaning shifts unutterably.

Rinpoche left and people began crowding out of the hall. Still bathed in the radiance, Grendel and I sat still and waited until the place was nearly cleared, then we slowly walked towards the doors.

As we inched our way around the crowded foyer, someone tapped me on the shoulder. I turned to see a man dressed in the robes and shaved head of a Buddhist monk but with the features of a Euro-American. Smiling, he said that it was really good to have brought my dog here. This was music to my ears.  Smiling back, I asked why. He said that Grendel’s having gone through this initiation would make it much more likely that she would be able to procure a human body for her next life. To which I laughed and joked that she’s already been there, done that, and gone on now to this much higher form.

He looked quite shocked and disapproving. Oh no, he informed me. The human is the highest and best, that which all beings aspire to, the prized end of this merry-go-round. So I pointed out to him that only humans are writing that script. And therefore, it might wind up being a tad ego-based, with us predictably on top. He didn’t get it: This hierarchy, to him, was a Truth.

Our conversation reminded me of a number of simple but troublesome questions with which we grapple around the category of “all sentient beings.” Who is included? Why or why not? The Chinese Madhyamika master Chi-t’sang long ago used the phrase, “Buddhahood attained by plants and trees.” Dogen composed a “Mountains and Rivers Sutra.”  And contemporary Zen priest Judith Kinst quotes an old koan at Tassajara Monastery, “The stones preach the Dharma.” In light of these teachings, is the positing of a linear hierarchy of beings even appropriate? To me, it seems clear that in an interconnected and dependently co-arising web, the idea of one species holding a “higher” position is illusion; the rain is not “better” or “more highly evolved” than the snow.

Grendel and I walked out the glass doors and down the hill to our truck. I had taken her off the leash when we left the building; there was no need for either of us to be restrained now. We walked together side-by-side, simply and joyfully, two beings consciously choosing to be together.

Many wise people throughout the ages, including the Buddha himself, have warned that “with our thoughts we create the world.”  What do we, as a culture and as individuals, create with our thoughts and actions concerning beings in other-than-human bodies? One little change in words, and the meaning shifts unutterably.


Tina Fields’ friend and teacher Grendel P. Slippersbane passed away at age 13.


24 Responses to “All Sentient Beings”

  1. Karin Says:

    Thank you.

    I came to All Sentient Beings on your website as an apprentice contra dance caller searching for “tech contra” information — I’d like to enrich the appeal of contras for young people by building on the patterns of technology in their lives.

    I am also an interpretive guide for seasonal walks, night hikes, and wildflower walks here in Michigan. As in the role of caller, I love to support people’s curiosity, encourage exploration of an activity that enriches their lives, and carry on in the traditions that connect with the goodness in our world.

    If you have time… what are you discovering that weaves ecopsychology through the life of the contradance community?
    I long to have dancers join me on a walk and to have hikers come and dance… how do we interconnect the two for others?


  2. Tina Fields Says:

    Hello Karin –

    How nice to hear from a kindred spirit, also involved in both contradance and outback awareness!

    You know, the simplest way that comes immediately to mind is to hold dances outside. One of the best dances I ever attended was in Maine, part of the MOFGA (Maine organic farmers & growers’ assn) Common Ground festival. It was held on a hill, and as over a hundred dancers weaved in and out, it felt very ancient. I love how the young permaculture folks are re-discovering the importance of these old, no-tech-required ways of building community. Folks can even laugh joyfully about being rained on if the dance is good enough.

    Or conversely, how about culminating a hike with an informal dance on a hilltop or beach or grove? I’ve found that people often start out feeling shy, but wind up blown away and expanded, when someone like you dares to lead them in activities that forge connection and joy.

    Thank you again for writing. I’d enjoy hearing about your further explorations into connecting the two.

    With best wishes,

  3. Steve Gaddis (facebook link) Says:

    Truly, isn’t there a koan that asks “does a dog have the Buddha nature”? Now we know!

  4. Rene Averett (Facebook link) Says:

    Remembering Grendel with deep fondness… Love and hugs to you, Tina…

  5. Jeff Rogge (Facebook link) Says:

    I loved hearing your Grendel stories.

  6. Anne Burnett (Facebook link) Says:

    Raising a toast in her memory.

  7. Patricia Layton (Facebook link) Says:

    I remember Grendel. You brought her to the Reg Office at CIIS.

    • Tina Fields Says:

      Yep! I loved taking her to work with me. Her unofficial title became “Attitude Adjustment Officer,” because nobody who encountered her could stay crabby for long.

  8. Nicky Duenkel (Facebook link) Says:

    Shanti send licks!

  9. Todd Lee (Facebook link) Says:

    Finnigan sends puppy kisses

  10. Cyndee Joncas (Facebook link) Says:

    Grendel was awesome! Miss her, too

  11. Gina Barnett (Facebook link) Says:

    Tina, I too remember Grendel with great fondness. She used to take a bath by swimming in one of the lakes in Golden Gate Park. 🙂

  12. Carol King (Facebook link) Says:

    One of the best around.

  13. Steve Gaddis (facebook link) Says:

    I remember Grendel as a puppy-she looked just like Fizgig from “Dark Crystal’ when she barked. My favorite memory is going for a walk in Golden Gate Park with Tina. Grendel would stop at a gopher hole and wait, then suddenly snap her head up flinging a gopher into the air and then catching it-crunch-crunch-crunch and it was gone. Grendel had great personality (caninality?)

  14. Jesica Lancaster (Facebook link) Says:

    Grendel!!! Oh my goodness! She still sets a standard in my mind as to what a 4-legged girl friend should be. I like seeing this picture because it assures me that she’s as beautiful as I remember.

  15. Joanne Burnett (Facebook link) Says:

    My favorite memory of Grendel is of the tme she and my Candy stood shoulder to shoulder at the front door, barking and growling at Gary as he tried to break in! And when I think of her, I see her with you–always.

  16. Kaleo Ching (Facebook link) Says:

    grendel, you’re such a loving soul

  17. […] To read more about spirituality involving dogs, see my essay All Sentient Beings. […]

  18. Oh, your story totally made me laugh and cry!! I’m absolutely with you on the human hierarchy script being written by humans!! Every being is composed of the same universal energy, intelligence, love, and creative power. Bravo to you for giving such a wonderful opportunity to Grendel to have a blessing that I’m sure helped her in her transition. If she’s anything like my Montana (the love of my life–a German shepherd:, she’s with you every moment in spirit. Thank you for bringing this beautiful story to my attention!!

  19. Grendel Says:

    I still miss my Grendel who died in July of 2009 at the age of 14. She was McKenzie River Husky/Akita and very wise. Since she was part McKenzie, she was probably part wolf as well. I looked today for “I love Grendel the dog,” and found your posts. Thank you for sharing.

    • BrujaHa Says:

      I love that you searched for “I love Grendel the dog.” (Did you find anything else?)
      And I’m very sorry for your loss.

  20. earthblessings Says:

    Thank you for this story! It was engaging, as if I was right there with you. Also, your honesty with the monk was inspiring.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s